Carney’s Command at Dawn (2)

Fortunately, I won’t be reviewing Command at Dawn. The book came out last year. And my love for the book is personal, not likely to be shared by the reading public. To be honest in a review, I’d have to point out the writing flaws that prevent the novel from being a top runner. I believe that Carney writes about Vietnam for the same reason I do: to vent his Post-Traumatic Stress Injury (PTSI). At the end of the text is a note that says the book “is the result of writing to stay sane.”

The novel ends with Ledbetter returning to the U.S. He is greeted by mobs that spit on him and call him “butcher” and “baby killer.” I experienced those rebukes repeatedly each time I came home from Vietnam with the troops starting in 1968. Like Ledbetter, I didn’t speak of my time in Vietnam for decades after the war ended. Like him, when I was finally received warmly, the emotions overwhelmed me. The first time a young person hugged me and said, “Thank you for your service. And welcome home,” I cried.

This isn’t the first time a book about Vietnam has awakened my anxieties. Over the years, it’s happened many times. The memories that cause PTSI never go away and never weaken. It doesn’t take much to trigger them. A sound, a smell, words from long ago—anything can bring them back. So much of my writing was done to help me vent those unbearable memories. Every little bit helps. But I’ll never be healed.

2 thoughts on “Carney’s Command at Dawn (2)”

  1. Tom, I have read your comments about “Command at Dawn”. You say your love of the book would not be likely be shared by the reading public. I guess that I am confused, if you love the book why would your view be any different than the people who reviewed the book on Amazon.


  2. Thanks for the comment, Melvin. What I meant was that my personal experience closely matches the events described in “Command at Dawn.” That’s not true of many other people. People may love the book for reasons that have nothing to do with their experience during the Vietnam war. Many, perhaps most, readers weren’t even born when the war was raging. Most of my writing is about Vietnam. Between 1962 and 1975, I was there more than i was in the states. My job was undercover signals intelligence in support of U.S. military forces. You can see my books at


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: